The Wolverine & Rogue Fanfiction Archive
Barely Legal Since 2000
Date: 11/20/2011 6:28:29 PM Title: Harmless
Whoa, that is intensely sad. I actually love this story and am so happy you've include Steve Rogers in it. But I'm so torn! I want her with Logan because they are just so....them. But I also want her with Steve because he's sweet and caring and appreciates her and not only that but is willing to overtly show it.
Author's Response: have to admit, you hit the nail on the head in this review: a willingness to overtly court wolvie's favourite girl shows cap's got a major brassy pair on him. thanks for the review
Date: 11/20/2011 5:08:11 PM Title: Harmless
Can't wait for the last chapter - great story.
Author's Response: hey, just wanted to say a belated thanks for this review, hope you liked the conclusion :-)
[Report This]Date: 11/18/2011 2:19:54 AM Title: Harmless
Wow, I actually have been looking forward to this chapter for what seems like days. I don't remember the last time I was so excited to read a story, so thank you! It made my day to see that it was updated today!
I'm actually conflicted because I love Logan and Marie and I want Logan to be happy but I also kind of really like this whole Rogue/Rogers thing thats going on! Gah. That's what good writing does to me.
Amazing job on this chapter, I can't wait for the next one!
Author's Response: hey, glad you're enjoying the steve/rogue match- at least you were when you wrote this, lol. thanks for the review!
Date: 11/18/2011 12:34:43 AM Title: Harmless
So... on a scale of one to ten, how bad is it that I really want Rogue to end up with Cap in this? And it's so bizarre, because I am such a hardcore Rogan fan. But the way you've written Steve's character (also a fan of CapAm and especially for a first time portrayal - you've got him so down) - I just really want him to end up with Rogue.
The realism of that just really sits with me, I think. Logan is her first love (maybe even her true love) but just because you're in love with someone and are "meant" to be together, doesn't mean it always works out that way. Steve is the guy I feel she loves as well and, had Logan not come along, she'd have been perfectly happy with him for the rest of her life. And they seem to have just such an easy relationship together - it's a simplistic beauty. Versus with Logan, there's this raging fire of emotion there and undoubtedly being with him would mean she'd get burned quite a lot (even when he doesn't mean to hurt her - and vice versa).
But with Steve - I feel like, yeah, it might never be this burning passion, but it's a different kind of love - a solid one. Where you're not second guessing yourself all the time.
And now I'm rambling...
I'm sure whomever you pair her with in the end will be wonderful. All I can say is that you know it's a good story when you have caused a die-hard Rogan fan to start surfing the web for Rogue/Captain America fics...
PS - this very well might be the only one. Dang it!
Author's Response: hey, just wanted to say thanks for this review. i agree that i think steve and marie make a good- if seldom seen in fanfic- match (and as a die-hard rogan shipper myself, how creepy is that for me?) you managed to sum up a lot of why i think they work too: katherine hepburn famously said "love is a fire, but whether it's going to warm your hands or burn down your house, you can't tell in the beginning." and i think that's the choice rogue has right there: major arson or a warm hearth. by now you've probably read the conclusion so you know which i chose, and i hope you enjoyed the chapter. thank you again for such a lovely review and hobbits away, hey!
Date: 11/17/2011 11:46:59 PM Title: Harmless
I love this love triangle between Rogers, Rogue, and Logan. Rogue definitely deserves to be happy. I can't wait to find out what will happen on Rogue's date and what she will do when she comes home! Please post the next chapter soon :)
Author's Response: just wanted to say thanks (belatedly) for the review. i agree, rogue deserves to be happy. hope you enjoyed the conclusion.
[Report This]Date: 11/17/2011 8:10:16 PM Title: Harmless
Oh MAN. That's all I can say. You write Jean so well.
Author's Response: thank you, i try. (and it's not easy because she's not someone i feel a lot of affinity for). thanks (belatedly) for the review.
[Report This]Date: 11/17/2011 2:06:12 PM Title: Harmless
Aww... poor Wolvie :(. Gah, that must really suck, knowing that he and Rogers were both government experiments yet the results came out so different. I didn't think about that.
Also, Jean=bitch. But you did make her reasonably sympathetic, so kudos. Please please please give us a Rogan ending. Please? I like Captain America and all, but Wolverine and Rogue are like, my OTP 4eva, y'know? And they're so meant to be in this story. He doesn't even want Jean cuddles when he's upset. Bad Jean cuddles. That should tell us something, right there. I just hope Logan and Rogue both come to their senses!
Author's Response: hi, i know this is a little late but i wanted to thank you for the above review. have to say, i knew from the beginning that this wouldn't end up being rogan (it's why i tried to be so up-front with everyone, rather than getting their hopes up). i'm therefore happy that you gave the story a chance anyway. i personally feel like, yeah, logan's in pain and with someone he might not really want but a lot of it is self-inflicted. at the end of the day rogue deserves to be happy, even if it's with steve... so i think wolvie will just have to settle for bad jean cuddles ;-)
Date: 11/17/2011 12:29:13 PM Title: Harmless
wow. that was emotional. Have to say, still hate Jean. She knows she is hurting Rogue and likes it. And jeeze. How big a mess are logan and Marie gonna make for themselves. Just talk to each other for heaven sake!
Author's Response: hi, i didn't get a chance to respond last night when i was posting the final chapter but i wanted to say thanks for this review, and i hope you enjoy the final chappie. cheers