silverthorne [Contact]
Real name:
Member Since: 01/26/2008
Membership Status: Member

 
Reviews by silverthorne
Sequel to “Baby, It’s Cold Outside” – Christmas isn’t the only holiday that Logan and Rogue celebrate together.

Rated: Mature
Categories: Comicverse
Characters: None
Genres: Holiday
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 5932 - Hits: 3345
Complete?: Yes - Published: 01/03/2008 - Last Updated: 01/03/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 01/07/2011 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

This is one of the best stories on the board with believable reactions, characterizations, dialog, situations, well-handled use of time-shifting, and grammar. Far and away better than 99.9% of the overwrought, prepubescent stuff ("ooooh, gr8 chappie! mor plz!")that clogs fanfic sites like this. M Jules' "Zero Sum" is a gem!

“We can laugh, we can cry, and never see the strong hand of love hidden in the shadows.” Logan on the road. Sequel to “A Subtle Shift.”

Rated: PG
Categories: Comicverse
Characters: None
Genres: Shipper
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: Slow Revival
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 1963 - Hits: 2676
Complete?: Yes - Published: 01/03/2008 - Last Updated: 01/03/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 02/19/2008 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I enjoyed this story, but have a question...what was the pewter charm Logan bought at the gas station, and what happened to it? Was it something for Marie, and he didn't give it to her, or was it just a throwaway detail that got lost?

Logan has some thoughts regarding mortality.

Rated: PG-13
Categories: X1
Characters: None
Genres: Angst
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 1953 - Hits: 1531
Complete?: Yes - Published: 01/04/2008 - Last Updated: 01/04/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 12/07/2011 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Great story! Great capture of Logan's voice on a subject that's integral to understanding his character!

“He looked so young. So very young.” Logan’s first Christmas at the Mansion.

Rated: R
Categories: X1
Characters: None
Genres: Friendship
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 1639 - Hits: 2396
Complete?: Yes - Published: 01/04/2008 - Last Updated: 01/04/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 04/19/2019 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Awww...Love this vulnerable moment...just a fleeting glimpse of his younger self.

Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 11/15/2018 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Any story hinting at a Logan "before" is a joy to me! Nice job here ... "So very young." Makes me feel for all that he's lost.

Rogue has settled well into life at the Mansion, hasn't she? Logan might need a little help, from the one friend he got, but perhaps everyone else would be so much better off if he didn't. -
Just a plain and quite tame little shot of everyday life at the Mansion.

Rated: NC-17
Categories: X2
Characters: None
Genres: Friendship
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 7
Wordcount: 9278 - Hits: 35344
Complete?: No - Published: 01/06/2008 - Last Updated: 01/06/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 09/12/2009 Title: Chapter 7: Epilogue

I enjoyed this story very much, and especially liked your Logan, still a man so unused to others, and certainly unsed to and mistrustful of another's compassion. I see this is an
old" story...will you/are you writing more Logan/Marie or just Logan stories?

Author's Response: Hi there, geez, thanks for the FB after all this time! There\'s a LOT of half-finished stories sitting in my mind right now, but I have a life at the moment. Keep your fingers crossed that I get a bit of space for them, will you? :-)

Well...this is a story about being brought beyond limits, and what happens afterwards.

It's not pretty, and It's fairly disturbing going. So be warned. Seriously. Dark, angst, violence, disturbing imagery, you name it. Don't say I didn't tell you.

Rated: Mature
Categories: AU
Characters: None
Genres: Dark
Tags: None
Warnings: Rape/Non-Con

Series: None
Chapters: 4
Wordcount: 13245 - Hits: 27644
Complete?: Yes - Published: 02/24/2008 - Last Updated: 02/27/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 01/15/2011 Title: Chapter 1: Et Lux In Tenebris Lucet Part One

The complexities of their feelings for each other magnified and twisted in the sheer horror of their captivity, and then dealing with the emotional damage in the aftermath is just masterful writing. Nothing rushed, nothing farfetched, nothing unbelievably out of character, not just for Logan and Marie, but also for the other X-Men here. Thank you for a beautiful story.

Rogue can't take it anymore.

Rated: PG
Categories: X1
Characters: None
Genres: Humor
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 1109 - Hits: 2655
Complete?: Yes - Published: 02/25/2008 - Last Updated: 02/25/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 02/26/2008 Title: Chapter 1: Needs

A smirk and a lift of the eyebrow to you...this short story has all the elements of the "Logan protecting Marie" genre -- the distress that she'll leave him, and then the happy realization that they can leave camping full-time and still want to be together. Very nice.

"It’ll have to do… For now.”

Rated: PG-13
Categories: AU, X1
Characters: None
Genres: Drabble
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 929 - Hits: 2421
Complete?: Yes - Published: 03/05/2008 - Last Updated: 03/05/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 03/05/2008 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I like the depictions of Logan as tough, then as he watches Marie, vulnerable. A beautiful scene. Will this turn into something longer, perhaps?

Author's Response: I don\'t know if I will return to this or not, yet. But thanks for the fb. Always appreciated. :)

Logan returns for Marie and they both learn the truth.

Rated: PG-13
Categories: X3, X1
Characters: None
Genres: Angst
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 7364 - Hits: 3244
Complete?: Yes - Published: 03/07/2008 - Last Updated: 03/07/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 03/07/2008 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

A beautiful story, with Logan and Marie's emotional pain laid bare after the 2-year separation, and Marie setting a pious Scott and Xavier straight on her sense of love.

Author's Response: Thank you for fb I\'m glad you enjoyed it x

A student at the school puzzles over a mystery. Pretty Rogue-centric.

Rated: PG
Categories: X1
Characters: None
Genres: Drama
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 2205 - Hits: 1956
Complete?: Yes - Published: 03/30/2008 - Last Updated: 03/30/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 07/15/2010 Title: Chapter 1: The Story

Excellent, well-written story from another point of view. The narrator is a wonderful character and close observer. Why this hasn't gotten more comment, is a mystery, as well.

The Way X-2 Should Have Ended. (damn the bastards that didn’t follow my way of thinking)

Rated: PG
Categories: X2
Characters: None
Genres: Shipper
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 605 - Hits: 2166
Complete?: Yes - Published: 04/01/2008 - Last Updated: 04/01/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 03/06/2019 Title: Chapter 1: Until Then

I like that he admits an admiration for Jean - an appreciation, too - but not love. This is a more mature beginning for a real Logan/Marie relationship. Nicely done!

Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 03/06/2019 Title: Chapter 1: Until Then

I like that he admits an admiration for Jean - an appreciation, too - but not love. This is a more mature beginning for a real Logan/Marie relationship. Nicely done!

May-December romance in more ways than one. An epistolary epiphany.

Rated: R
Categories: X2
Characters: None
Genres: Shipper
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 7546 - Hits: 2976
Complete?: Yes - Published: 04/13/2008 - Last Updated: 04/13/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 08/09/2019 Title: Chapter 1: Songs of a Wayfarer

Lovely...a pleasure to read...even after all these years.

Logan's on the run. Written for Khaki's Opening Sentence Challenge.

Rated: PG-13
Categories: X2
Characters: None
Genres: Shipper
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 607 - Hits: 1300
Complete?: Yes - Published: 04/20/2008 - Last Updated: 04/20/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 12/22/2010 Title: Chapter 1: Salvation

Nice, short piece, full of feeling, and he's so tired of running. Marie can return the favor by picking him up and taking him off the road this time. Very nice.

Patterns.

Rated: G
Categories: X1
Characters: None
Genres: Drama
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 107 - Hits: 1568
Complete?: Yes - Published: 05/02/2008 - Last Updated: 05/02/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 10/07/2009 Title: Chapter 1: Un-Stability

A familiar W/R story covered succinctly -- less is definitely much, much more when handled adroitly.

retired featured story An Alterverse version of our favorite couple. Inspired, sorta, by Terri Berri's "Naked Animal Guy."

Rated: NC-17
Categories: AU
Characters: None
Genres: Shipper
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 12508 - Hits: 7557
Complete?: Yes - Published: 11/24/2008 - Last Updated: 11/24/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 08/10/2019 Title: Chapter 1: The Lab

One of the very best "they meet in a lab" stories. I reread this one from time to time, and never fail to be drawn into their horror...and their hope. Love both of them in this. Great story, very well-written.

Christmas is hard. And Logan has the gift stash to prove it.

Rated: R
Categories: X2
Characters: None
Genres: Holiday, UST
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 1526 - Hits: 4333
Complete?: Yes - Published: 12/09/2008 - Last Updated: 12/09/2008
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 12/22/2010 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I guess there was never a sequel? Oh, well. Merry Christmas, anyway, everyone - especially Marie and Logan!

Author's Response: Thank you and I hope you had a wonderful Christmas too. Funnily enough, I\'ve just written the first chapter in a new story, that might actually be able to pass as a sequel to this. I\'m hoping to post in a week or so ... it\'s called The Wanting Time and is just going to beta today. Thank you for reading - and reviewing!

Gratuitous wet man foof (stapled roughly to a thin plot along the lines of Logan takes the younger X-team out on a survival training exercise *g*)

Rated: R
Categories: AU
Characters: None
Genres: Foof
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 1012 - Hits: 3545
Complete?: Yes - Published: 02/02/2009 - Last Updated: 02/02/2009
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 01/12/2011 Title: Chapter 1: Gratuitous wet man foof

Wet Logan muse, indeed! I hope he shows up again real soon! Well-written, hot little ficlet.

With Rogue captured by The Brotherhood and Logan dead set on getting her back, the two struggle with their respective roles in the coming war between mutants and humanity.

Fourth in the Dark Side of the Moon series. Same premise, different consequences owing to a treatment facility for mutants called Southaven and a focus on the chemistry between Logan and Rogue.

Rated: R
Categories: X1, AU
Characters: None
Genres: Action, Drama, Shipper
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: Dark Side of the Moon
Chapters: 6
Wordcount: 32502 - Hits: 31425
Complete?: Yes - Published: 03/18/2009 - Last Updated: 09/24/2010
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 08/17/2019 Title: Chapter 4: Life and limb for a kiss of death

Without a doubt, these last few paragraphs are the most beautiful and insightful interpretation of the iconic scene that is the core of this fandom and the reason I am still devoted to Logan after all these years and all the disappointing X-men movies later. Thank you!

Rogue and Wolverine become closer, and not in a way he expected.

Rated: NC-17
Categories: X3
Characters: None
Genres: Action, Adult, Humor, Shipper
Tags: None
Warnings: Animal Death, Cutting, Not Beta Read

Series: None
Chapters: 22
Wordcount: 36518 - Hits: 161023
Complete?: No - Published: 03/21/2009 - Last Updated: 04/05/2009
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 10/03/2009 Title: Chapter 22: Another gift

James? James!! Nuh-uh!! No!! I do not care what "great revelations" have transpired during the Quesada era or what the current Marvel machine wants to do with a loved character. I do not know this James Howlett, whoever he is. My Wolverine will always be Logan...just Logan.

Logan takes a teaching position at Xavier's.

Rated: PG
Categories: X1
Characters: None
Genres: Drama
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: to Know, to Teach, to Learn
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 3607 - Hits: 2156
Complete?: Yes - Published: 04/11/2009 - Last Updated: 04/11/2009
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 11/22/2011 Title: Chapter 1: To Teach

This is one of my all-time favorite stories from one of my all-time favorite authors. The way Logan handles both the older and the younger students without condescending to either group; the way he disappears in the woods, but is still keeping an eye on them; the way Rogue explains the story of their meeting; Scott's testing of Logan's fighting skills in the Danger Room and his discussion with Xavier about Logan as a danger to them and Xavier's thoughts that Logan might be the one in more danger; and Logan's subliminal reaction to "Saving Private Ryan." This is truly one of my very favorite stories and series. Tinhutlady, you are a "Marvel!"

Author's Response: (blushes) It\'s been ten years (?) since I took a chance and wrote this rough little tale. It means a great deal that someone enjoyed reading it as much as I enjoyed writing it. Thank you.

Epilogue. Logan learns a few things about his past.

Rated: PG
Categories: X1
Characters: None
Genres: Drama
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: to Know, to Teach, to Learn
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 1530 - Hits: 2392
Complete?: Yes - Published: 04/11/2009 - Last Updated: 04/11/2009
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 12/07/2011 Title: Chapter 1: Yes

I am so glad I have these stories of your - many of which are sequential - all grouped together and printed into a book that I can read and reread and hug to myself! Thank you for this output, tinhutlady. I've always liked to start with this little series which begins with a "no" and ends with a "yes." Simply wonderful writing!

Logan reminisces with an old friend.

Rated: G
Categories: X1
Characters: None
Genres: General
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: The Megan Stories
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 1530 - Hits: 1711
Complete?: Yes - Published: 04/13/2009 - Last Updated: 04/13/2009
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 02/22/2011 Title: Chapter 1: The Last Fairytale

I rather prefer this version of the story - ending, as it does, with him telling one more story to an aged Megan - to the longer version in which he returns a year later.... This is sad and sweet, and is a perfect ending for the collection of your stories I put together. As always, I am happy every time I reread your work.

While Logan is ‘babysitting,’ an inspector comes to call at the mansion…

Rated: G
Categories: X1
Characters: None
Genres: Humor
Tags: None
Warnings: None

Series: None
Chapters: 1
Wordcount: 4529 - Hits: 3458
Complete?: Yes - Published: 04/14/2009 - Last Updated: 04/14/2009
Reviewer: silverthorne Signed
Date: 04/15/2009 Title: Chapter 1: Artful Dodging

A thoughtful, view of Logan and his place at the school, told in your wonderfully nuanced style...welcome to this new WRFA, tinhutlady. You are and continue to be one of my favorite writers. I hope your other stories will be making the transition here - although, I love your own site, as well. best wishes to you!

Author's Response: Thank you for such kind words. My apologies that I did not seem them sooner than this, but I am just now figuring out this new archive. Like, today. (LOL) I thought I was still gathering dust in the old one. Once I find out how to post here, I might add to, but really, I don\'t think there would be an audience anymore. Thank you again for your kindness.