The Wolverine & Rogue Fanfiction Archive
Barely Legal Since 2000
I spent a lot of time thinking about how I should review this and couldn't come up with a satisfactory answer. So I'll just say that it's very powerful and it definitely moved me. I know that's not very good but I couldn't seem to put words to the emotions I felt. Fantastic job =)
I think you got their accents down very well. It was awesome.
Author's Response: Thanks so much for taking time to let me know you enjoyed this and that I got their accents right. It\'s such a dilemma -- deciding whether to write the accents or not -- but something about the playful nature of this bunny sort of lent itself to dialogue with accents as opposed to without. Thanks again. --Wendie
This story is amazing. It is totally awesome and completely epic. I absolutely love it. There was action, mystery, suspense, romance, adorableness, angst, and awesomeness. I think I already said the awesome part but that is because it is doubly awesome. Thanks for sharing such a fantastic story.
You rock =D
Author's Response: You are very kind. I\'m proud to hear this old story can still amuse and entertain. You made my day. Thank you.
Fantastic story =)
Author's Response: Aw, thanks. You are ridiculously sweet. Love the name! ;-)
Absolutely chilling. I mean it! *shivers*
Can't wait for more. I'm excited =)
Author's Response: I\'m excited that you\'re excited. I hope to have more out soon. Thanks so much for reading and reviewing.
First of all, fantastic start. Just thought I'd write things I really like.
I think that describing what happened to Marie as rape is very accurate and truly conveys what it feels like to her when they force her to absorb someone.
Author's Response: So glad you liked the start! Yeah, Marie being forced to take someone into her mind has always seemed like such a violation -- for her, and for her \"victim.\" Thanks for your review -- all of them!
Logan covering her exposed toe is *so* incredibly sweet.
Author's Response: Yeah, it\'s funny sometimes how characters take on a life of their own. When I wrote the description of Marie\'s torn stockings I was just trying to flesh out the visual, and then once Logan was checking her over he kinda did that all on his own. My reaction to it was pretty much Marie\'s...it was just so sweet of him! Thanks for your review!
The torture was quite evocative. When I was reading it, it felt like it was going on forever (not in a dragging way but in a so-full-of-emotion-and-detail way). But then I went back and looked at it and was surprised at its length.
Author's Response: What a compliment! Yeah, to be honest, I had a vague notion of Logan and Marie having to take advantage of a brief window of touchability eventually, and that\'s why I put in the two-hour delay until the collar kicks in. And then I realized I had written myself into a corner, and had to make it seem reasonable that two hours pass from the time they take collar off Marie until the time she takes them down. I felt like the torture was getting repetitive, but I wanted to make sure it seemed to fill the appropriate time span. Thanks for your review!
The last bit was incredibly sweet. You always think of Logan as the lone wolf (wolverine) but to see that he is happy she is there as he dies is wonderful.
Author's Response: Yeah, poor Logan. Thinking that the best he can hope for is to die in someone else\'s company. So glad he lives. ;-) Thanks for your review!
The bit where she pulls out the briefcase? Brilliant. They're both so pragmatic and clear-headed. It's quite impressive.
Author's Response: Yeah, I like the slow reveal of all the practical things Marie did while Logan was out. Put her gloves back on and put his leather jacket on to protect him, took the briefcase, brought the car around...she\'s quite street-smart. Thanks for your review!
This Marie is very strong. I'm glad. She kicks ass. Even when she's crying.
Author's Response: I\'m so glad you liked it. I kept editing and re-editing this because she was coming across too \"weak\" to me. Still not sure if I got that mix of vulnerability and strength and prickliness I was looking for. Thanks for reviewing!
Your description of what happened while she went through the memories was just gut-wrenching. Huzzah for Logan being there.
Author's Response: Yeah, poor Marie. Her mutation can be a curse in many different ways. She can gain immense knowledge, but at incredible cost to her. Thanks for reviewing!
No, Logan, don't fight it!
The description of Marie asleep was quite beautiful.
Author's Response: Aw, it wouldn\'t be good Rogan angst if he didn\'t fight it! Thanks for reviewing!
I think Marie's reaction to Xavier's intrusion was perfect. It just makes so much sense that she wouldn't want more voices in her head.
Also, you made Jean beyond mean. She was like, evil!Jean. I loved how Scott admonished her, just like she was a student or something.
Such twists and turns! Don't hold out on me. You better reveal things soon.
Author's Response: Yeah, it makes sense to me that both Logan and Marie would *hate* Xavier\'s telepathy. Yeah, Mean!Jean was a little over-the-top. My first attempt at a Mean!Jean, I need to calibrate a little better next time. Thanks for reviewing!
It wouldn't be a proper Dr. G story without more complications!
The pain she feels when she sees there aren't any scars is poignant. She will forever remember what happened, be able to live it, but his body shows no proof.
Author's Response: Yes, the lack of scars is so unnerving...I think in some ways it lets Logan feel like what happens to him doesn\'t really matter...that if he can deal with the pain it won\'t have a lasting impact, but it still does. Thanks for reviewing!
I liked how Erik still understands Charles enough to know when to stop mocking -- if only for a moment.
Author's Response: Yes, knowing Kitty and Jubilee are at risk raises the stakes considerably. Enough to sober Lehnsherr, if only for a moment. Thanks for your review!
I always think of Ororo as elegant in her speech so she's allowed to wax poetic.
I could almost imagine velcro being torn apart as Marie and Logan parted. =P
Oh Marie, always trying to be so brave.
Author's Response: Yeah, I think if anyone is going to introspect about the Rogan relationship, Ororo is a good one to do it. Thanks for reviewing!
I'm amused how everyone seems to know what's going on but Logan.
I was a bit worried about Owen but when he perked up at the mention of the jet, I was glad.
Author's Response: The man can be a little dense sometimes, huh? Yeah, Owen was a little shell-shocked I think, but he\'ll recover. Thanks for reviewing!
Marie's panic was riveting. I felt everything closing in on her, drowning her, trapping her. Quite intense.
Hope she's not off being foolish. Accept the love, Marie. ACCEPT!
Author's Response: I\'m glad you liked it. I had no idea when I started the chapter that she would have a panic attack, but it just seemed to happen. And of course she\'s off doing something foolish! ;-) Thanks for reviewing!
Oh no! How will Marie deal with this? I'm getting distracted by the intense story to remember to write down the bits I liked.
Erik is ruthless as always. Very glad they were able to take him down. I don't think I could stand them being captured again so soon.
Author's Response: :-D Hope you liked how Marie dealt. Yes, Erik is ruthless, and he is brilliant. He never does anything without a good reason. :-D Thanks for reviewing!
Absolutely fabulous. All of it. I often struggle with myself about how I would do feral!Marie (if it should arise in a story). I think your take is very interesting.
Author's Response: So glad you liked it! As much as I have Marie absorb Logan every story (I think it\'s such an integral part of her character to have Logan in her head) I don\'t think I\'ve ever done a fully Feral!Marie. It was fun! Although it made me miss atmd more!
A superb exploration of the interplay between the Wolverine and Logan. I absolutely cannot wait for more. (Good thing it's already there =P)
Author's Response: I\'m glad you liked it...there\'s always a hard line to hit I think with the duality of this character without making it outright absurdly Jekyll and Hyde. I like the idea of the feral sending him unconscious messages that get a little lost in translation sometimes for the man. Thanks so much for your review!
I could never yell at you! They're just not ready yet. Definitely had to happen this way. Though of course, I'm a bit sad Marie is still so closed off but it's unrealistic to expect her to change long ingrained habits. Their interaction was heart-wrenching and real.
Author's Response: Yeah...now that they have actually gotten there (smutty chapters ahead) it confirmed for me how very not-ready they were back then. Marie is closed-off and prickly, that\'s the defining characteristic I had in mind when I was envisioning her. I\'m glad you liked the interaction. Thanks for reviewing!
Stacy is a very interesting character. I'm with Ororo in expressing distress at her rather cavalier attitude about killing a man but he *did* buy her. With nefarious intentions, no less. Never read about someone quite like her.
Author's Response: Yeah, I didn\'t know too much about Stacy, but the more I read about her the more interesting she became to me. She is quite the survivor. I really liked the idea of one of the mutants \"saving themselves\" rather than waiting around to be rescued. Thanks for reviewing!