this is actually kinda sad. poor Marie.

Kinda sad when you think about it. Marie and Logan being together but not in love with each other in the end.

That's it?

come on Rogue should be more pissed at Logan.

Anyway, I enjoy reading this story very much. Here's hoping you'll continue it.

So okay I have a question
Did they meet before? because the 10 years line is confusing me right now.

Is it Jean's name?

huh. Scott and Logan.

I think it's Logan.

I read this story 4 times now and this is the first time that I have the urge to left you a comment. I read this whenever I feel like my life is not going to the direction that I want it to. I learned a lot by reading it. How Rogue is determined to shed the immature image. How she realized that we’re the only one who could shape ourselves and the only one to do something in order to get what we need in our life. No one else would help us. We help ourselves.

The first time I read the story, I felt an instant connection with the way Rogue is evolving to be from teenager to adult. I had my fair shares of mistakes and I realize so does Rogue. The difference between me and her is that she learned from her mistake the first time around. It took me awhile to get the message and change my way.

And her not believing in hope anymore is something that I understand. From time to time, even if I’m not hoping for something anymore, I just really wanted someone to prove me wrong. But it didn’t happen yet. And I really want to have someone like Kurt. A friend that I could talk to without them being judgmental.
The whole concept of observing others and copy their fine traits is something that I approved of.
So there. I know this is not a constructive criticism but I just feel the need to thank you for producing such a wonderful story that somehow I can relate to.

Author's Response: Wow. All I can say is that I\'m so touched by this feedback. I\'m so pleased you could relate and that it makes you think. There\'s really no other reason to write. Thank you so much.

OMG! I freaking love this! Logan should be aware that he always cry at the end of every x-men movies though.

Author's Response: heh heh, thank you for reminding me. the next movie i\'ll be sure to point that out. esp. how he blubbers with that stupid cracking voice in the Blackbird after Jean \"dies\"

Reading this feels like a jolt of electric surging through my vein. Very nice.

Bravo!

I know it's not Christmas anymore. But, I feel all happy inside :)

Author's Response: Well if it helps I\'ll watch White Christmas any time of year. Glad to know I can spread the happy as well as sad.

That's so good I can't wait for another one.

Author's Response: Thank you! I\'m now working on the next chapter so expect updates today or tomorrow!

OH LOGAN YOU STUPID STUPID MAN!

but yes I didn't see that one coming. Gosh, I feel so loved up by you because I was reading chapter 4 at my work place and now I'm reading chapter 5 at my house.

MOAR SOOOOON!!! - alia

Author's Response: I find it funny how some people are able to predict what I\'m gonna write and others not. I\'m glad I suprised you. I\'ll try and have another chapter up today or tomorrow. Thank you for reviewing! Sophie