You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Capt_Mackenzie Signed star star star star half star [Report This]
Date: 12/24/2010 1:55:33 AM Title: Chapter 10

aw. Sha bebe! (as the Cajuns say) Very sweet ending.

I kinda didn't like the part where (once again) you tried to just copy-n-paste the X1 movie dialogue. There were some places where, yes, the symmetry/irony of certain lines felt great, but not ALL the lines fit the new situation you had written. Watch out for those things! I suggest, next time you're tempted to write such a scene, that you go back an hour or two after all the editing is done and read JUST that small section of dialogue ... to help you get the sense of how well that scene stands alone, and to help you see it with "fresh eyes", so to speak, as much as possible.

And, I found it quite remarkable how quickly Logan got his energy back -- one minute he's struggling to walk across the medlab, the next he's traversing the entire length of Xavier's vast lawn & gardens without even leaning on Marie for support, and energetically pacing back & forth! Hee Hee. I think you get what I'm saying. It may sound like I'm nit-picking, but I'm doing it for your benefit. Overlooking small but important details disrupts the logical continuity of the events in each scene, and weakens your whole story. I know you can do better b/c you definitely have talent! All you lack is the care to spend enough editing time to catch these things! Don't be in too much of a hurry to post ... we're willing to wait for high quality!

Still, this is a smartly-written tale overall. Your big strength, as I've said before, is to get across your characters' feelings. Just take care to balance the sappiness with some good plot points as you have more or less managed successfully thus far.

I realize it's been a long time since you've touched this story. Please don't abandon it now!

Reviewer: Rogue1189 Signed star star star star star [Report This]
Date: 04/15/2009 2:49:19 PM Title: Chapter 10

"Well, you can tell her my heart belongs to someone else"

That line right there that you twisted into your own way had tears running down my face. Literally. That was how it was supposed to be damn it! Just writing that had me so happy I am sooooo happy!

haha anyways!

Great addition to the story and I knew he would be understanding of everything. Nice to see that they are starting to connect even more as Logan and Marie realize their love for each other.

ahhhh *big sigh*

Author's Response: Thanks so much! Let me tell you, every time that part comes up in the movie I always imagine him saying that to Marie. You are right, that is how it was supposed to happen! I'm glad that I could make you happy. Our favorite couple has a long way to go before they can find happiness though. Their whole world is about to be turned upside down!

Reviewer: Anami Signed [Report This]
Date: 04/15/2009 1:53:06 PM Title: Chapter 10

Aaaawwwww. And don't kill Jean. If you kill her, she will not be able to suffer. A lot.

Author's Response: LOL, so far Jean isn't going to die...but the littlest thing about her might set me off and I will take care of her...we will see!

You must login (register) to review.